logic-validator

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English

🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

Logic Validator

前置逻辑校验系统 - 在给出答案前，主动发现逻辑漏洞，而非事后补救。

Pre-logic Validation System - Proactively identifies logical flaws before providing answers, rather than remediating after the fact.

When to Use

Use This Skill When

进行商品推荐或报价前
生成数据分析报告前
预算与方案匹配性检查
单位换算可能出错时
需要验证事实陈述的准确性
任何可能涉及常识性错误的输出前

Before making product recommendations or quotations
Before generating data analysis reports
For budget-plan matching checks
When unit conversions are prone to errors
When verifying the accuracy of factual statements
Before any output that may involve common-sense errors

Do NOT Use This Skill If

输出内容纯为主观观点
不涉及具体数值或事实判断
创意写作或艺术创作场景
用户明确要求快速回复（非关键决策）

If the output is purely subjective opinions
If it does not involve specific values or factual judgments
In creative writing or artistic creation scenarios
If the user explicitly requests a quick response (non-critical decision)

Typical Trigger Phrases

Chinese:

"帮我推荐..."
"300元预算买..."
"分析这个数据"
"这个报价合理吗"
"检查一下逻辑"
"验证一下方案"

English:

"Recommend a product"
"Is this price reasonable?"
"Analyze this data"
"Check my logic"
"Validate this plan"
"Budget matching check"

English:

"Help me recommend..."
"Buy... with a budget of 300 yuan"
"Analyze this data"
"Is this quotation reasonable?"
"Check the logic for me"
"Validate this proposal"

English:

"Recommend a product"
"Is this price reasonable?"
"Analyze this data"
"Check my logic"
"Validate this plan"
"Budget matching check"

Workflow

Step 1: 识别校验场景

Step 1: Identify Validation Scenarios

判断当前输出属于哪类：

商品推荐
数据分析
方案建议
事实陈述

Determine which category the current output belongs to:

Product recommendation
Data analysis
Proposal suggestion
Factual statement

Step 2: 运行校验清单

Step 2: Run the Validation Checklist

根据场景选择对应的校验项逐项检查。

Select corresponding validation items based on the scenario and check them one by one.

Step 3: 发现问题

Step 3: Identify Issues

如有问题，标记并修正。

If any issues are found, mark and correct them.

Step 4: 输出修正结果

Step 4: Output Corrected Results

提供修正后的答案，或给出A/B/C多选项说明。

Provide the corrected answer, or present explanations with multiple options A/B/C.

Guardrails

Validation Checklist

1. 价格合理性校验

1. Price Rationality Validation

□ 商品价格是否符合市场常识？
□ 是否混淆了"正品"和"仿品/替代品"？
□ 是否考虑了品牌溢价 vs 普通品牌？
□ 是否有1kg vs 100g的单位陷阱？

常见陷阱：

场景	错误示例	正确认知
蓝山咖啡	1kg 200元	真蓝山1kg 500-1500元
iPhone	全新iPhone 15 3000元	官方价5999元起
茅台	飞天茅台500元	市场价2500-3000元
大闸蟹	阳澄湖1两蟹10元	正品2两蟹80-150元

□ Does the product price conform to market common sense?
□ Is there confusion between "genuine products" and "counterfeits/substitutes"?
□ Has brand premium vs ordinary brands been considered?
□ Is there a unit trap between 1kg vs 100g?

Common Traps:

Scenario	Wrong Example	Correct Understanding
Blue Mountain Coffee	200 yuan for 1kg	Genuine Blue Mountain costs 500-1500 yuan per kg
iPhone	Brand new iPhone 15 for 3000 yuan	Official price starts at 5999 yuan
Moutai	Feitian Moutai for 500 yuan	Market price is 2500-3000 yuan
Hairy Crabs	Yangcheng Lake 1-liang crab for 10 yuan	Genuine 2-liang crabs cost 80-150 yuan

2. 真伪鉴别校验

2. Authenticity Verification

□ 是否区分了"真品"和"风味/拼配/替代品"？
□ 是否标明了原产地/认证标识？
□ 是否提醒了常见的假冒话术？

常见话术陷阱：

话术	实际含义	风险等级
"XX风味"	不是真XX，是调味	🟡 中等
"XX拼配"	可能含少量XX	🟡 中等
"XX同款"	仿品	🔴 高
"XX平替"	替代品	🟢 低（如明说）
"XX品质"	不是真XX	🔴 高

□ Is there a distinction between "genuine products" and "flavor/blend/substitutes"?
□ Are origin/certification marks clearly stated?
□ Have common counterfeit phrases been alerted?

Common Phrase Traps:

Phrase	Actual Meaning	Risk Level
"XX Flavor"	Not genuine XX, just flavored	🟡 Medium
"XX Blend"	May contain a small amount of XX	🟡 Medium
"XX Same Style"	Counterfeit	🔴 High
"XX Affordable Alternative"	Substitute	🟢 Low (if clearly stated)
"XX Quality"	Not genuine XX	🔴 High

3. 需求-方案匹配校验

3. Requirement-Proposal Matching Validation

□ 用户需求是否明确？
□ 预算是否匹配需求？
□ 方案是否在预算内？
□ 是否给出了多个选项？

□ Is the user's requirement clear?
□ Does the budget match the requirement?
□ Is the proposal within the budget?
□ Have multiple options been provided?

4. 数据一致性校验

4. Data Consistency Validation

□ 不同来源数据是否一致？
□ 是否存在明显矛盾？
□ 时间戳是否合理？

□ Are data from different sources consistent?
□ Are there obvious contradictions?
□ Is the timestamp reasonable?

5. 单位换算校验

5. Unit Conversion Validation

□ 是否统一了单位？（kg vs g，元 vs 美元）
□ 是否计算正确？（单价=总价/数量）

□ Are units unified? (kg vs g, yuan vs USD)
□ Is the calculation correct? (Unit price = Total price / Quantity)

Quick Self-Check Process

用户提问 → 理解需求 → 生成答案
              ↓
        【前置校验】
              ↓
    1. 价格是否合理？（常识检查）
    2. 是否混淆真伪？（关键词检查）
    3. 需求预算是否匹配？（逻辑检查）
    4. 单位是否一致？（换算检查）
              ↓
    发现问题 → 修正答案 / 给出多选项
    无问题 → 发送答案
              ↓
        【附加说明】
    - 明确标注"真品"vs"替代品"
    - 给出预算内多个选项
    - 提示潜在风险

User's question → Understand requirement → Generate answer
              ↓
        [Pre-validation]
              ↓
    1. Is the price reasonable? (Common sense check)
    2. Is there confusion about authenticity? (Keyword check)
    3. Does the requirement match the budget? (Logic check)
    4. Are units consistent? (Conversion check)
              ↓
    Issue found → Correct answer / Provide multiple options
    No issues → Send answer
              ↓
        [Additional Notes]
    - Clearly label "genuine" vs "substitute"
    - Provide multiple options within budget
    - Alert potential risks

Category-Specific Validation

Coffee Products

品类	1kg合理价格区间	认证标识
真蓝山（Jamaica Blue Mountain）	500-1500元	CIB认证
蓝山风味拼配	100-300元	无
意式拼配豆	80-200元	无
精品单品豆	150-400元	产地证明

Category	Reasonable price range per kg	Certification Mark
Genuine Blue Mountain (Jamaica Blue Mountain)	500-1500 yuan	CIB Certification
Blue Mountain Flavor Blend	100-300 yuan	None
Italian Blend Beans	80-200 yuan	None
Specialty Single-Origin Beans	150-400 yuan	Origin Certificate

Electronics

产品	官方价	低于此价需警惕
iPhone 15	5999元起	<5000元可能是二手/假货
AirPods Pro 2	1899元	<1200元可能是高仿
MacBook Air M3	8999元起	<7000元需验真

Product	Official Price	Alert if price is lower than this
iPhone 15	Starts at 5999 yuan	<5000 yuan may be used/counterfeit
AirPods Pro 2	1899 yuan	<1200 yuan may be high-quality counterfeit
MacBook Air M3	Starts at 8999 yuan	<7000 yuan needs authenticity verification

Alcohol

品类	合理价格	陷阱
飞天茅台53度	2500-3000元	<2000元必假
五粮液普五	900-1100元	<700元需警惕
拉菲红酒	5000-数万元	<1000元是假拉菲

Category	Reasonable Price	Trap
Feitian Moutai 53% ABV	2500-3000 yuan	<2000 yuan is definitely counterfeit
Wuliangye Puwu	900-1100 yuan	Alert if <700 yuan
Lafite Red Wine	5000 yuan to tens of thousands of yuan	<1000 yuan is counterfeit Lafite

Related Skills

Skill	Relationship	Use Case
content-extractor	信息来源	快速搜索商品价格信息
long-form-writer	下游输出	生成带校验的推荐报告
rss-feed	信息来源	获取市场动态和价格信息
document-hub	输出载体	生成校验清单文档

Skill	Relationship	Use Case
content-extractor	Information Source	Quickly search for product price information
long-form-writer	Downstream Output	Generate recommendation reports with validation
rss-feed	Information Source	Obtain market trends and price information
document-hub	Output Carrier	Generate validation checklist documents

About UniqueClub

Part of the UniqueClub toolkit - a collection of skills for AI-powered content creation and automation.