sales-loyalty

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English
🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

Customer Loyalty Programs

客户忠诚度计划

Help the user design and manage loyalty programs — from strategy and structure through points/tiers/rewards mechanics, member engagement, and ROI measurement. This skill is tool-agnostic but includes platform-specific guidance for Brevo Loyalty, Smile.io, LoyaltyLion, Yotpo, Stamp.me, and custom-built solutions.
帮助用户设计和管理忠诚度计划——从策略、架构到积分/等级/奖励机制、会员参与度优化以及ROI衡量全流程覆盖。本技能不限制工具使用,同时提供Brevo Loyalty、Smile.io、LoyaltyLion、Yotpo、Stamp.me以及定制化解决方案的平台专属指导。

Step 1 — Gather context

步骤1 —— 收集上下文信息

Ask the user:
  1. What do you need help with?
    • A) Program design — creating a new loyalty program from scratch
    • B) Tool selection — choosing loyalty program software
    • C) Points & rewards — setting up earning rules and reward catalog
    • D) Tiers / VIP — designing tier levels and progression
    • E) Member engagement — increasing participation and redemption
    • F) Analytics & ROI — measuring program effectiveness
    • G) Integration — connecting loyalty to e-commerce, CRM, or POS
    • H) Migration — switching loyalty platforms
    • I) Something else — describe it
  2. What type of business?
    • A) E-commerce / DTC
    • B) Retail (physical stores)
    • C) SaaS / subscription
    • D) Hospitality / restaurants
    • E) B2B
    • F) Multi-location / franchise
    • G) Other
  3. Current loyalty setup?
    • A) No program yet — starting from scratch
    • B) Using Brevo Loyalty
    • C) Using Smile.io
    • D) Using LoyaltyLion
    • E) Using Yotpo
    • F) Using a custom-built solution
    • G) Using another platform
    • H) Have a basic program (punch card, discount codes) but want to upgrade
If the user's request already provides most of this context, skip directly to the relevant step. Lead with your best-effort answer using reasonable assumptions (stated explicitly), then ask only the most critical 1-2 clarifying questions at the end.
询问用户以下问题:
  1. 你需要哪方面的帮助?
    • A) 方案设计 —— 从零搭建全新的忠诚度计划
    • B) 工具选型 —— 选择忠诚度计划软件
    • C) 积分与奖励 —— 设置赚取规则和奖励兑换池
    • D) 等级/VIP —— 设计会员等级和升级规则
    • E) 会员参与度 —— 提升参与率和兑换率
    • F) 分析与ROI —— 衡量项目有效性
    • G) 集成对接 —— 将忠诚度系统与电商、CRM或POS系统打通
    • H) 迁移 —— 切换忠诚度平台
    • I) 其他需求 —— 请描述具体内容
  2. 你的业务类型是什么?
    • A) 电商/DTC
    • B) 线下零售
    • C) SaaS/订阅制
    • D) 酒店餐饮
    • E) B2B
    • F) 多门店/加盟连锁
    • G) 其他
  3. 当前的忠诚度配置是怎样的?
    • A) 还没有相关计划 —— 从零开始
    • B) 使用Brevo Loyalty
    • C) 使用Smile.io
    • D) 使用LoyaltyLion
    • E) 使用Yotpo
    • F) 使用定制化解决方案
    • G) 使用其他平台
    • H) 已有基础计划(集点卡、折扣码)但需要升级
如果用户的请求已经提供了大部分上下文信息,可以直接跳转到对应步骤。 优先基于合理假设(需明确说明假设内容)给出你能提供的最优答案,最后再提出1-2个最关键的澄清问题即可。

Step 2 — Strategy and approach

步骤2 —— 策略与落地方法

Loyalty program types

忠诚度计划类型

TypeHow it worksBest forExample
PointsEarn points on purchases, redeem for rewardsE-commerce, retail1 point per $1 spent, 100 points = $5 off
TieredHigher tiers unlock better perksBrands wanting aspirational statusSilver → Gold → Platinum with increasing benefits
Paid / VIPPay for membership with exclusive benefitsPremium brands, Amazon Prime model$99/year for free shipping + early access
CashbackEarn store credit on purchasesPrice-sensitive customers5% back on every purchase
Punch cardBuy X, get 1 freeCafes, salons, simple retailBuy 10 coffees, get 1 free
ExperientialRewards are experiences, not discountsLuxury brandsEarly access, exclusive events, personal styling
类型运行逻辑适用场景示例
积分制消费赚取积分,积分兑换奖励电商、零售每消费1美元得1积分,100积分可抵扣5美元
等级制更高等级解锁更优权益希望打造身份感的品牌白银→黄金→铂金,权益随等级提升
付费/VIP制付费购买会员资格获取专属权益高端品牌、Amazon Prime模式每年99美元享免邮费+优先购权益
返现制消费可获得店铺积分抵扣额度对价格敏感的用户群体每笔消费返现5%
集点卡制购买X次获1次免费权益咖啡馆、美发店、小型零售买10杯咖啡送1杯
体验式奖励为体验权益而非折扣奢侈品品牌优先购买权、专属活动、私人造型服务

Program design framework

方案设计框架

  1. Define the objective — retention, AOV increase, purchase frequency, referrals, data collection?
  2. Choose the model — points, tiers, paid, hybrid?
  3. Set earning rules — how do customers earn? (purchases, reviews, referrals, social shares, birthdays)
  4. Design rewards — what can they redeem? (discounts, free products, free shipping, exclusive access, charity donations)
  5. Create tiers (optional) — 2-4 tiers with clear progression and meaningful benefits at each level
  6. Plan communication — welcome email, points reminders, tier upgrade notifications, expiry warnings
  7. Measure — enrollment rate, active rate, redemption rate, incremental revenue
  1. 明确目标 —— 是提升留存、AOV、复购率、推荐量还是数据收集?
  2. 选择模式 —— 积分、等级、付费还是混合模式?
  3. 设置赚取规则 —— 客户如何获取积分?(消费、评价、推荐、社交分享、生日福利)
  4. 设计奖励体系 —— 可以兑换什么?(折扣、免费商品、免邮、专属权限、慈善捐赠)
  5. 搭建等级体系(可选) —— 2-4个等级,每个等级有清晰的升级路径和实质性权益
  6. 规划触达策略 —— 欢迎邮件、积分提醒、升级通知、过期预警
  7. 数据衡量 —— 注册率、活跃率、兑换率、增量收入

Points economy design

积分体系设计

Earning rules (typical):
  • Purchase: 1 point per $1 spent (or 10 points per $1 for psychological effect)
  • Account creation: 50-100 points (one-time)
  • Birthday: 50-200 points (annual)
  • Product review: 25-50 points
  • Social share/follow: 10-25 points
  • Referral: 100-500 points
Redemption value:
  • Target 5-10% effective discount rate (e.g., 100 points = $5 on a program where you earn 1 point/$1)
  • Don't make rewards too hard to reach — first reward should be achievable in 2-3 purchases
  • Offer a mix of reward values ($5, $10, $25, free product, free shipping)
常见赚取规则:
  • 消费:每消费1美元得1积分(或每1美元得10积分,优化心理感知)
  • 账号注册:50-100积分(一次性)
  • 生日福利:50-200积分(每年1次)
  • 商品评价:25-50积分
  • 社交分享/关注:10-25积分
  • 推荐好友:100-500积分
兑换价值设置:
  • 目标有效折扣率控制在5-10%(例如每消费1美元得1积分的体系下,100积分抵扣5美元)
  • 不要让奖励门槛过高 —— 首次奖励应该在2-3次消费后即可获得
  • 提供不同价值的奖励选项(5美元、10美元、25美元抵扣、免费商品、免邮)

Tier design

等级体系设计

  • 2-3 tiers is ideal — more than 4 creates confusion
  • Name tiers — use brand-relevant names, not just Bronze/Silver/Gold
  • Clear progression — spend $X/year or earn X points to reach next tier
  • Meaningful benefits — each tier must feel noticeably better (not just 1% more discount)
  • Maintain status — require annual re-qualification to maintain tier (prevents dormant high-tier members)
  • 2-3个等级为最优配置 —— 超过4个会造成用户困惑
  • 等级命名 —— 使用和品牌相关的名称,不要仅用青铜/白银/黄金这类通用名称
  • 清晰的升级路径 —— 明确年消费X美元或赚取X积分即可升级到下一级
  • 实质性权益差异 —— 每个等级的权益要有明显感知提升(不能仅仅是多1%的折扣)
  • 等级保级规则 —— 要求每年重新达到保级标准(避免休眠的高等级会员占用资源)

Step 3 — Platform-specific guidance

步骤3 —— 平台专属指导

In Brevo

Brevo平台

  • Product: Brevo Loyalty — full loyalty engine with points, tiers, rewards, vouchers, mobile wallet
  • Key concepts: Programs, Subscriptions (enrolled members), Balances (points), Tiers, Rewards, Vouchers
  • API: Comprehensive REST API for all loyalty operations — program management, subscription enrollment, balance transactions, tier assignment, voucher creation/redemption
  • Mobile wallet: Digital loyalty cards on Apple Wallet / Google Pay (Enterprise only)
  • Strength: Integrated with Brevo's email/SMS/WhatsApp — loyalty events can trigger marketing automation (e.g., tier upgrade → congratulations email, points expiring → reminder SMS)
  • Limitation: Enterprise plan only — not available on Starter/Standard/Professional
  • Best for: Teams already using Brevo for marketing who want integrated loyalty without a separate tool
  • Platform skill:
    /sales-brevo
  • 产品: Brevo Loyalty —— 完整的忠诚度引擎,支持积分、等级、奖励、优惠券、移动钱包
  • 核心概念: 计划、订阅(已注册会员)、余额(积分)、等级、奖励、优惠券
  • API: 覆盖所有忠诚度操作的完整REST API —— 计划管理、会员注册、余额变动、等级分配、优惠券生成/兑换
  • 移动钱包: 支持Apple Wallet / Google Pay数字会员卡(仅企业版可用)
  • 优势: 与Brevo的邮件/SMS/WhatsApp功能深度集成 —— 忠诚度事件可触发营销自动化(例如等级升级→发送祝贺邮件,积分即将过期→发送提醒短信)
  • 限制: 仅企业版可用 —— 入门版/标准版/专业版不支持
  • 适用场景: 已经使用Brevo做营销,希望无需额外工具即可获得集成忠诚度能力的团队
  • 平台专属技能:
    /sales-brevo

In Smile.io

Smile.io平台

  • Product: Popular loyalty platform for Shopify, BigCommerce, Wix
  • Programs: Points, VIP tiers, referrals — all in one
  • Free tier: Up to 200 monthly orders
  • Strength: Best Shopify integration. Easy setup, good-looking widget. Strong referral program built in.
  • Limitation: Limited customization on lower plans. Advanced analytics on higher tiers only.
  • Best for: Shopify stores wanting a quick, attractive loyalty program
  • 产品: 面向Shopify、BigCommerce、Wix的热门忠诚度平台
  • 支持计划类型: 积分、VIP等级、推荐,一站式覆盖
  • 免费版: 支持每月最多200笔订单
  • 优势: 业内最好的Shopify集成,配置简单,界面美观,内置成熟的推荐计划
  • 限制: 低阶计划自定义能力有限,高级分析功能仅高阶计划可用
  • 适用场景: 想要快速搭建美观的忠诚度计划的Shopify店铺

In LoyaltyLion

LoyaltyLion平台

  • Product: E-commerce loyalty platform with deep analytics
  • Programs: Points, tiers, custom rewards, loyalty pages
  • Strength: Advanced analytics and segmentation. Can create custom loyalty pages. Good for data-driven teams.
  • Limitation: Higher starting price. Setup is more complex.
  • Best for: Mid-market e-commerce brands wanting detailed loyalty analytics
  • 产品: 具备深度分析能力的电商忠诚度平台
  • 支持计划类型: 积分、等级、自定义奖励、忠诚度专属页面
  • 优势: 高级分析和分群能力,可创建自定义忠诚度页面,适合数据驱动的团队
  • 限制: 起步价格更高,配置更复杂
  • 适用场景: 需要精细化忠诚度数据分析的中端电商品牌

In Yotpo

Yotpo平台

  • Product: Part of Yotpo's retention marketing suite (loyalty + reviews + SMS + email)
  • Programs: Points, tiers, referrals, VIP
  • Strength: Combines loyalty with reviews and UGC — customers earn points for reviews, which generates social proof. Unified retention platform.
  • Limitation: Most powerful as a suite — loyalty alone may be expensive. Complex pricing.
  • Best for: E-commerce brands wanting loyalty + reviews + SMS in one platform
  • 产品: Yotpo留存营销套件的一部分(忠诚度+评价+SMS+邮件)
  • 支持计划类型: 积分、等级、推荐、VIP
  • 优势: 将忠诚度与评价、UGC能力结合 —— 客户写评价可赚积分,同时生成社交证明,是一体化的留存平台
  • 限制: 作为套件使用时能力最强,单独使用忠诚度功能性价比低,定价复杂
  • 适用场景: 希望在一个平台获得忠诚度+评价+SMS能力的电商品牌

In Stamp.me

Stamp.me平台

  • Product: Digital loyalty card and stamp program
  • Programs: Digital punch cards, points, tiered rewards
  • Strength: Simple and affordable. Mobile-first with digital stamp cards. Good for brick-and-mortar.
  • Limitation: Less sophisticated than full loyalty platforms. Limited e-commerce integrations.
  • Best for: Cafes, restaurants, salons, and small retail with simple loyalty needs
  • 产品: 数字会员卡和集章计划工具
  • 支持计划类型: 数字集点卡、积分、等级奖励
  • 优势: 简单实惠,移动优先的数字集卡设计,适合线下门店
  • 限制: 能力不如全功能忠诚度平台成熟,电商集成能力有限
  • 适用场景: 有简单忠诚度需求的咖啡馆、餐厅、美发店、小型零售商家

Custom-built

定制化开发

  • When: Unique business model, specific integration needs, or very high volume (millions of members)
  • Approach: Build on your database + API layer, or use headless loyalty APIs
  • Strength: Complete control and customization
  • Limitation: Significant development effort, ongoing maintenance
  • Best for: Enterprise with unique requirements or companies where loyalty is a core competitive advantage
  • 适用场景: 商业模式独特、有特殊集成需求,或体量极大(数百万会员)的业务
  • 落地方案: 基于自有数据库+API层开发,或使用无头忠诚度API
  • 优势: 完全可控,可高度自定义
  • 限制: 开发工作量大,需要持续维护
  • 适用场景: 有独特需求的企业,或者将忠诚度作为核心竞争力的公司

Step 4 — Actionable guidance

步骤4 —— 可落地指导

Launch checklist

上线检查清单

  1. Design program — model, earning rules, rewards, tiers (see Step 2)
  2. Choose platform — based on your e-commerce stack and needs
  3. Configure — set up program, earning rules, reward catalog, tiers
  4. Design assets — loyalty page, widget, emails (welcome, points earned, reward available, expiry warning)
  5. Set up automations — trigger emails/SMS based on loyalty events
  6. Soft launch — test with a small group, verify points earning and redemption
  7. Promote — announce via email, site banner, checkout page, social media
  8. Measure — track enrollment, engagement, and revenue impact weekly
  1. 方案设计 —— 模式、赚取规则、奖励、等级(参考步骤2)
  2. 平台选择 —— 基于你的电商技术栈和需求选择
  3. 配置调试 —— 搭建计划、设置赚取规则、奖励池、等级
  4. 物料设计 —— 忠诚度页面、组件、邮件模板(欢迎、积分到账、奖励可用、过期提醒)
  5. 自动化配置 —— 基于忠诚度事件触发邮件/SMS
  6. 灰度上线 —— 小范围测试,验证积分赚取和兑换流程正常
  7. 正式推广 —— 通过邮件、网站横幅、结账页、社交媒体发布上线公告
  8. 数据监测 —— 每周跟踪注册量、参与度、收入影响

Key metrics

核心指标

MetricBenchmarkWhat it tells you
Enrollment rate20-40% of customersProgram attractiveness
Active member rate40-60% of enrolledOngoing engagement
Redemption rate20-40% of points issuedReward appeal
Member vs non-member AOV15-25% higherRevenue impact
Member purchase frequency20-40% higherRetention impact
Program ROI3-5x costOverall program value
指标行业基准代表含义
注册率20-40%的用户计划的吸引力
会员活跃率40-60%的注册会员持续参与度
兑换率已发放积分的20-40%奖励的吸引力
会员vs非会员AOV高15-25%收入影响
会员复购率高20-40%留存影响
项目ROI成本的3-5倍整体项目价值

Gotchas

注意事项

  1. Don't make the first reward unreachable — if it takes 10 purchases to earn the first reward, most customers will give up. Design the first reward to be achievable in 2-3 purchases.
  2. Don't create too many tiers — 2-3 tiers with meaningful differences beats 5 tiers with marginal distinctions. Each tier should feel like a real upgrade.
  3. Don't forget expiration communication — if points expire, you must warn members before expiration (30 days, 7 days, 1 day). Surprise expiration creates angry customers.
  4. Don't discount your way to losses — if your effective discount rate exceeds your margin, the program loses money. Model the economics before launch (typical target: 5-10% effective discount).
  5. Don't neglect non-purchase engagement — the best loyalty programs reward reviews, referrals, social engagement, and account actions — not just purchases. This keeps members engaged between purchases.
  1. 不要把首次奖励的门槛设得太高 —— 如果需要消费10次才能拿到首次奖励,大部分客户会放弃。首次奖励应该设置为2-3次消费即可获得。
  2. 不要设置太多等级 —— 2-3个有实质权益差异的等级比5个只有微小差异的等级效果更好,每个等级都应该让用户感受到明显的升级体验。
  3. 不要忽略积分过期通知 —— 如果积分有有效期,必须在过期前提醒会员(30天、7天、1天),突然过期会引起客户不满。
  4. 不要因为折扣造成亏损 —— 如果有效折扣率超过你的毛利率,项目就会亏损。上线前要做好经济模型测算(常规目标:有效折扣率5-10%)。
  5. 不要忽略非消费类的参与行为 —— 优秀的忠诚度计划会奖励评价、推荐、社交互动、账号操作等行为,而不仅仅是消费,这能让会员在消费间隔期保持活跃。

Related skills

相关技能

  • /sales-brevo
    — Brevo platform help (Brevo Loyalty setup and configuration)
  • /sales-affiliate-program
    — Affiliate and referral programs with commission payouts
  • /sales-email-marketing
    — Email communication for loyalty program members
  • /sales-checkout
    — Checkout optimization (loyalty display at checkout)
  • /sales-integration
    — Connect loyalty tools with e-commerce and CRM
  • /sales-do
    — Not sure which skill to use? The router matches any sales objective to the right skill. Install:
    npx skills add sales-skills/sales --skills sales-do
  • /sales-brevo
    —— Brevo平台帮助(Brevo Loyalty搭建与配置)
  • /sales-affiliate-program
    —— 有佣金支付的联盟和推荐计划
  • /sales-email-marketing
    —— 面向忠诚度计划会员的邮件沟通
  • /sales-checkout
    —— 结账优化(结账页展示忠诚度信息)
  • /sales-integration
    —— 忠诚度工具与电商和CRM的对接
  • /sales-do
    —— 不知道该用哪个技能?路由工具可将任何销售目标匹配到正确的技能。安装命令:
    npx skills add sales-skills/sales --skills sales-do

Examples

示例

Example 1: Designing a loyalty program for a Shopify store

示例1:为Shopify店铺设计忠诚度计划

User says: "I run a DTC skincare brand on Shopify with $80 AOV. How should I structure a loyalty program?" Skill does: Recommends points-based program with 2 tiers. Earning: 1 point/$1 + bonus points for reviews and referrals. Rewards: $5 off (50 points), $15 off (150 points), free mini product (100 points). Tiers: Regular + VIP (spend $500/year for 1.5x points, free shipping, early access). Recommends Smile.io for Shopify. Result: Complete program design with economics, platform recommendation, and launch plan
用户提问: "我经营一个Shopify上的DTC护肤品牌,AOV是80美元,我该怎么搭建忠诚度计划?" 技能输出: 推荐采用2个等级的积分制计划。赚取规则:每消费1美元得1积分+评价和推荐的额外积分。奖励:5美元抵扣(50积分)、15美元抵扣(150积分)、免费小样(100积分)。等级:普通会员+VIP(年消费满500美元享1.5倍积分、免邮、优先购权益)。推荐Shopify使用Smile.io平台。 结果: 包含经济模型、平台推荐、上线计划的完整方案设计

Example 2: Measuring loyalty program ROI

示例2:衡量忠诚度计划ROI

User says: "Our loyalty program has been running for 6 months and we're not sure if it's working" Skill does: Defines key metrics to pull (member vs non-member AOV, purchase frequency, retention rate, redemption rate). Provides benchmark comparisons. Identifies common issues (low engagement, unreachable rewards, no communication). Result: Measurement framework with specific metrics, benchmarks, and optimization recommendations
用户提问: "我们的忠诚度计划已经运行了6个月,不确定效果怎么样" 技能输出: 明确需要提取的核心指标(会员vs非会员AOV、复购率、留存率、兑换率),提供基准对比,识别常见问题(参与度低、奖励门槛高、缺少沟通)。 结果: 包含具体指标、基准值、优化建议的衡量框架

Example 3: Setting up Brevo Loyalty with email automation

示例3:配置带邮件自动化的Brevo Loyalty

User says: "We're on Brevo Enterprise and want to launch a tiered loyalty program with automated emails" Skill does: Walks through creating a loyalty program in Brevo → defining tiers and earning rules → setting up reward catalog → building automation journeys triggered by loyalty events (enrollment → welcome, tier upgrade → congratulations, points expiring → reminder) Result: Loyalty program configured in Brevo with automated email flows for all key moments
用户提问: "我们用的是Brevo企业版,想要上线带自动化邮件的等级制忠诚度计划" 技能输出: 分步指导:在Brevo创建忠诚度计划→定义等级和赚取规则→搭建奖励池→配置忠诚度事件触发的自动化流程(注册→欢迎邮件、等级升级→祝贺邮件、积分即将过期→提醒邮件)。 结果: Brevo中配置完成的忠诚度计划,覆盖所有关键节点的自动化邮件流

Troubleshooting

问题排查

Low enrollment rate

注册率低

Symptom: Less than 10% of customers joining the loyalty program Cause: Program not visible enough, value proposition unclear, or signup process too complex Solution: 1) Add loyalty callout on homepage, product pages, and checkout. 2) Offer sign-up bonus (50-100 points). 3) Simplify enrollment to 1 click (email only). 4) Show the first achievable reward at signup ("You're 2 purchases away from $5 off!").
症状: 不到10%的用户加入忠诚度计划 原因: 计划曝光不足、价值主张不清晰、注册流程太复杂 解决方案: 1) 在首页、商品页、结账页添加忠诚度引导。2) 提供注册奖励(50-100积分)。3) 简化注册流程为1步(仅需邮箱)。4) 注册页面展示可快速获得的首次奖励("你再买2次就能抵扣5美元!")。

Members not redeeming rewards

会员不兑换奖励

Symptom: High points issuance but low redemption (< 15%) Cause: Rewards not appealing, redemption process too complex, or members forget they have points Solution: 1) Survey members on desired rewards. 2) Simplify redemption (1-click at checkout). 3) Send points balance reminders monthly. 4) Add lower-tier rewards that are easier to reach. 5) Show points balance prominently on account page and in emails.
症状: 积分发放量高但兑换率低(<15%) 原因: 奖励没有吸引力、兑换流程太复杂、会员忘记自己有积分 解决方案: 1) 调研会员想要的奖励类型。2) 简化兑换流程(结账页1点击兑换)。3) 每月发送积分余额提醒。4) 增加更容易获得的低门槛奖励。5) 在账号页和邮件中突出展示积分余额。

Program losing money

项目亏损

Symptom: Loyalty program costs exceed the incremental revenue it generates Cause: Effective discount rate too high, or program attracts deal-seekers without increasing loyalty Solution: 1) Calculate effective discount rate (total rewards redeemed ÷ total member revenue). 2) If > 10%, reduce earning rate or increase redemption thresholds. 3) Add non-discount rewards (early access, exclusive content). 4) Implement minimum spend for redemption. 5) Segment: compare member lifetime value to non-member — if no difference, the program isn't driving incremental behavior.
症状: 忠诚度计划成本超过其带来的增量收入 原因: 有效折扣率太高,或者计划只吸引了薅羊毛的用户,没有提升真正的忠诚度 解决方案: 1) 计算有效折扣率(已兑换奖励总额 ÷ 会员总收入)。2) 如果超过10%,降低积分赚取比例或提高兑换门槛。3) 增加非折扣类奖励(优先购、专属内容)。4) 设置兑换最低消费门槛。5) 分群对比:如果会员和非会员的生命周期价值没有差异,说明项目没有带来增量行为改变。