Back to Details

rw-evidence-map

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English
🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

RW Evidence Map

RW Evidence Map

把研究、构念、设计、样本、结果、偏倚、冲突和缺口组织成可追溯证据图。
Organize research, constructs, design, samples, results, biases, conflicts, and gaps into a traceable evidence map.

启动

Initiation

  1. 读取 
    references/standalone.md
    、
    references/method.md
    和 
    references/standards.md
    。
  2. 读取用户本轮提供的材料；没有材料时，只完成当前证据允许的部分。
  3. 需要规则判断时检索 
    references/atoms.jsonl
    ；遇到相似任务时读取 
    references/cases.md
    。
  4. 需要选择方法或工具时读取 
    references/domain-guide.md
    ，并使用 
    assets/worksheet.md
    组织交付。
  5. 读取 
    references/acceptance.md
    。
    references/behavior-tests.json
    只用于测试，不作为用户任务事实。
  6. 当前文献、API、报告规范和期刊要求可能变化时，打开 
    references/source-map.md
    中的官方链接核验并记录日期。
  1. Read 
    references/standalone.md
    , 
    references/method.md
    and 
    references/standards.md
    .
  2. Read the materials provided by the user in this round; if no materials are provided, only complete the parts allowed by the current evidence.
  3. Retrieve 
    references/atoms.jsonl
    when rule judgment is required; read 
    references/cases.md
    when encountering similar tasks.
  4. Read 
    references/domain-guide.md
    when selecting methods or tools is needed, and use 
    assets/worksheet.md
    to organize deliverables.
  5. Read 
    references/acceptance.md
    . 
    references/behavior-tests.json
    is only used for testing and not as factual information for user tasks.
  6. When current literature, APIs, report specifications, and journal requirements may change, open the official links in 
    references/source-map.md
    for verification and record the date.

工作阶段

Work Phases

  1. 定义证据图服务的研究问题、决策和时间范围。
  2. 为每项研究建立稳定 ID，并连接原文或可核验标识符。
  3. 提取研究设计、人群、暴露或干预、比较、结果、时间和效应信息。
  4. 单独记录偏倚风险、适用性、精确性和直接性。
  5. 把关系标为支持、反驳、限制、不可比较或待核对。
  6. 输出证据簇、冲突原因、空白和下一步取证。
  1. Define the research questions, decisions, and time scope for the evidence map service.
  2. Establish a stable ID for each study and link it to the original text or verifiable identifiers.
  3. Extract information on study design, population, exposure or intervention, comparison, outcomes, timing, and effects.
  4. Record risk of bias, applicability, precision, and directness separately.
  5. Label relationships as supporting, refuting, limiting, incomparable, or pending verification.
  6. Output evidence clusters, causes of conflicts, gaps, and next steps for evidence collection.

运行规则

Operational Rules

  • 证据图先固定节点定义，再建立关系。
  • 研究结论和当前综合判断要分开保存。
  • 不同构念、测量工具或时间点不能因为名称相近就合并。
  • 效应方向、效应大小和不确定性要分开记录。
  • 无统计学显著性不等于没有效应。
  • 高偏倚风险研究可以保留，但不能与低风险研究等权处理。
  • 冲突先检查人群、设计、测量、分析和时间差异。
  • 证据缺口要区分没有研究、没有可用全文和结果未报告。
  • 每条严格关系必须有原文位置或结构化记录支持。
  • 证据确定性是结果层判断，不是给整篇论文贴一个分数。
  • 图谱可以显示关系，不能自动完成因果推断。
  • 新增证据要保留旧判断和变化原因。
  • The evidence map first fixes node definitions before establishing relationships.
  • Study conclusions and current comprehensive judgments must be stored separately.
  • Different constructs, measurement tools, or time points cannot be merged just because their names are similar.
  • Effect direction, effect size, and uncertainty must be recorded separately.
  • Lack of statistical significance does not mean no effect exists.
  • Studies with high risk of bias can be retained but cannot be treated equally with low-risk studies.
  • When conflicts arise, first check for differences in population, design, measurement, analysis, and timing.
  • Evidence gaps should be distinguished between no research available, no full text accessible, and unreported results.
  • Each strict relationship must be supported by the original text location or structured records.
  • Evidence certainty is a judgment at the outcome level, not a score assigned to the entire paper.
  • The map can display relationships but cannot automatically complete causal inference.
  • When adding new evidence, retain the old judgments and reasons for changes.

输出

Output

  • 证据矩阵或关系图。
  • 关系来源、偏倚和可比性记录。
  • 冲突解释、缺口和下一步。
  • Evidence matrix or relationship diagram.
  • Records of relationship sources, biases, and comparability.
  • Conflict explanations, gaps, and next steps.

停止条件

Stop Conditions

  • 摘要不足以判断方法或结果时，标记待全文核对。
  • 缺少共同结果口径时，不做数值合并。
  • 不把图中连接数量当成证据强度。
  • 没有来源定位的关系只能进入候选区。
  • When the abstract is insufficient to judge the method or results, mark it as pending full-text verification.
  • Do not perform numerical merging when there is a lack of common outcome standards.
  • Do not treat the number of connections in the map as evidence strength.
  • Relationships without source localization can only enter the candidate area.

独立运行

Standalone Operation

  • 默认不读取私人工作区、个人语料目录或预设 research-lab。
  • 用户提供的文件、文本、链接和数据是当前任务输入，不是安装依赖。
  • 网络不可用时，使用 Skill 内的稳定方法继续；需要当前事实的部分标记为待核验。
  • 本包内其他科研 Skill 存在时可以接续；单独安装时直接返回下一步说明，不停止当前任务。
  • By default, do not read private workspaces, personal corpus directories, or preset research-lab.
  • Files, text, links, and data provided by the user are input for the current task, not installation dependencies.
  • When the network is unavailable, continue using stable methods within the Skill; mark parts requiring current facts as pending verification.
  • Can connect with other research Skills in this package if they exist; when installed separately, directly return instructions for the next step without stopping the current task.

来源纪律

Source Discipline

  • 把用户材料、公开来源、当前推断和未知事项分开。
  • 报告规范只检查报告透明度，不自动证明设计质量。
  • 公开来源摘要保存在 Skill 内；需要版本、费用、政策、API 或期刊现状时回到官方页面。
  • 不生成不存在的论文、数据、DOI、工具运行结果或期刊要求。
  • Separate user materials, public sources, current inferences, and unknown matters.
  • Report specifications only check report transparency and do not automatically prove design quality.
  • Public source abstracts are stored within the Skill; return to official pages when information on versions, fees, policies, APIs, or journal status is needed.
  • Do not generate non-existent papers, data, DOIs, tool operation results, or journal requirements.