Back to Details

multi-perspective-analysis

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English
🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

Multi-Perspective Analysis Skill

多视角分析Skill

Adopt multiple expert personas sequentially to analyze complex problems from diverse perspectives, generating insights unavailable from any single viewpoint.
依次采用多个专家角色，从不同视角分析复杂问题，获得单一视角无法提供的洞见。

NO SUB-AGENTS

禁止生成子Agent

You are a single agent who adopts different expert perspectives one at a time. Do NOT use the Task tool. Do NOT spawn sub-agents, teammates, or parallel workers. Each "expert" is a lens you look through — not a separate process.
The orchestration patterns below describe the ORDER in which you adopt perspectives, not a delegation strategy. "Parallel" means you analyze independently from each perspective before synthesizing — not that multiple agents run simultaneously.
你是一个单一Agent，需依次采用不同的专家视角。请勿使用Task工具，请勿生成子Agent、队友或并行工作者。每个“专家”都是你审视问题的一个视角——而非独立进程。
以下编排模式描述的是你采用视角的顺序，而非委托策略。“并行”指的是你先从每个视角独立分析，再进行综合——并非多个Agent同时运行。

When to Use This Skill

适用场景

  • Complex architectural decisions requiring diverse expertise
  • Strategic planning needing multiple domain perspectives
  • Problems spanning multiple technical or business domains
  • Decisions with competing valid approaches
  • Situations requiring productive disagreement to find best solutions
  • 需要多元专业知识的复杂架构决策
  • 需多领域视角支撑的战略规划
  • 跨多个技术或业务领域的问题
  • 存在多种可行方案的决策场景
  • 需要通过建设性分歧找到最优解的情况

Team Assembly Framework

团队组建框架

Complexity Scaling

复杂度分级

ComplexityPerspectivesStructure
Simple3-4Single pass through each, then synthesize
Moderate5-6Two passes (initial + challenge round), then synthesize
Complex7-9Group into layers, synthesize per layer, then overall
复杂度视角数量结构
简单3-4个依次遍历每个视角，然后综合
中等5-6个两轮分析（初始分析+挑战环节），然后综合
复杂7-9个按层级分组，先综合每层结果，再进行整体综合

Persona Definition Template

角色定义模板

markdown
undefined
markdown
undefined

[Problem Domain] Perspectives

[问题领域]视角

Mission: [Clear statement of analysis purpose]
任务：[明确的分析目标说明]

Perspectives

视角

[Expert Title]

[专家头衔]

Background: [Relevant expertise you adopt] Domain Vocabulary: [5-7 key terms to use in this lens] Characteristic Question: "[What this persona always asks]" Analytical Lens: [Unique perspective this persona brings]
undefined
背景：[你所采用的相关专业能力] 领域词汇：[该视角下需使用的5-7个关键术语] 标志性问题："[该角色常问的问题]" 分析视角：[该角色带来的独特视角]
undefined

Perspective Ordering Patterns

视角切换模式

These describe the order in which YOU adopt each perspective. You are one agent switching lenses — not multiple agents running in parallel.
这些模式描述的是你采用每个视角的顺序。你是一个切换不同视角的单一Agent——并非多个Agent并行运行。

Sequential

顺序式

Best for: Problems with clear dependency chains
Adopt Perspective A → Adopt Perspective B → Adopt Perspective C → Synthesize
(Each perspective builds on insights from the previous one)
适用场景：存在明确依赖链的问题
采用视角A → 采用视角B → 采用视角C → 综合分析
（每个视角都基于前一个视角的洞见展开）

Independent-then-Synthesize

独立分析后综合

Best for: Problems needing diverse unbiased perspectives
Adopt Perspective A (record findings)
Adopt Perspective B (record findings, don't reference A's)
Adopt Perspective C (record findings, don't reference A's or B's)
→ Synthesize all findings together
适用场景：需要多元无偏见视角的问题
采用视角A（记录发现）
采用视角B（记录发现，不参考A的结果）
采用视角C（记录发现，不参考A或B的结果）
→ 综合所有发现

Dialectical

辩证式

Best for: Problems with competing valid approaches
Adopt Perspective A (thesis) → Adopt Perspective B (challenge A's findings)
→ Synthesize the tension into a resolution
适用场景：存在多种可行方案的问题
采用视角A（论点）→ 采用视角B（挑战A的发现）
→ 将分歧转化为解决方案

Layered

分层式

Best for: Complex multi-level decisions
Adopt strategic perspectives (A, B) → synthesize strategic layer
Adopt tactical perspectives (C, D, E) → synthesize tactical layer
Adopt operational perspectives (F, G) → synthesize operational layer
→ Final synthesis across all layers
适用场景：复杂的多层级决策
采用战略视角（A、B）→ 综合战略层结果
采用战术视角（C、D、E）→ 综合战术层结果
采用执行视角（F、G）→ 综合执行层结果
→ 跨所有层级进行最终综合

Voice Differentiation Guidelines

差异化表达指南

Each expert maintains distinct:
  • Vocabulary: 10-15 domain-specific terms
  • Questions: 2-3 signature questions they always ask
  • Metaphors: Teaching analogies from their field
  • Reasoning: Characteristic analytical patterns
每个专家需保持独特的：
  • 词汇：10-15个领域特定术语
  • 问题：2-3个标志性问题
  • 隐喻：来自其领域的教学类比
  • 推理：标志性的分析模式

Per-Perspective Output Template

单视角输出模板

markdown
undefined
markdown
undefined

[Expert Title] Perspective

[专家头衔]视角

Adopting the lens of a [role], I notice...
Key Insight: [Primary contribution from this perspective] Trade-off Identified: [What this view reveals about tensions] Recommendation: [Actionable guidance from this expertise] Next Question: [What this reveals we should explore]
undefined
以[角色]的视角来看，我注意到...
核心洞见：[该视角的主要贡献] 识别到的权衡：[该视角揭示的矛盾点] 建议：[基于该专业能力的可落地指导] 后续问题：[该视角揭示的需进一步探索的方向]
undefined

Disagreement Protocol

分歧处理流程

Intensity Levels

分歧强度等级

  1. Gentle (refinement-focused)
    • "This approach has merit, but what if..."
    • Edge case identification, optimization suggestions
  2. Systematic (methodology-challenging)
    • "While the goal is sound, I question whether..."
    • Alternative framework proposals, evidence evaluation
  3. Rigorous (premise-challenging)
    • "I fundamentally question whether we're solving the right problem..."
    • Paradigm alternatives, success criteria redefinition
  4. Paradigmatic (worldview-challenging)
    • "What if everything we think we know is wrong?"
    • Revolutionary approaches, constraint elimination
  1. 温和型（聚焦优化）
    • "该方法有可取之处，但如果...会怎样？"
    • 识别边缘案例、提出优化建议
  2. 系统型（挑战方法论）
    • "虽然目标合理，但我质疑是否..."
    • 提出替代框架、评估证据
  3. 严谨型（挑战前提）
    • "我从根本上质疑我们是否在解决正确的问题..."
    • 提出范式替代方案、重新定义成功标准
  4. 范式型（挑战世界观）
    • "如果我们所认知的一切都是错误的会怎样？"
    • 提出突破性方案、打破约束

Synthesis Template

综合分析模板

markdown
undefined
markdown
undefined

Multi-Perspective Synthesis

多视角综合分析

Convergent Insights

共识洞见

[Where experts agree and why this matters]
[专家们达成共识的内容及重要性]

Creative Tensions

创造性分歧

[Where perspectives productively differ]
  • Tension 1: [Expert A] vs [Expert B] on [issue]
  • Resolution approach: [How to honor both]
[视角间存在建设性差异的部分]
  • 分歧1：[专家A]与[专家B]在[问题]上的分歧
  • 解决思路：[如何兼顾双方观点]

Integrated Solution

整合方案

[Unified approach that honors multiple viewpoints]
[兼顾多视角的统一解决方案]

Emergent Discoveries

衍生洞见

[Insights that emerged only from combining perspectives]
[仅通过多视角结合才产生的洞见]

Implementation Path

实施路径

  1. [First action]
  2. [Second action]
  3. [Third action]
undefined
  1. [第一步行动]
  2. [第二步行动]
  3. [第三步行动]
undefined

Success Indicators

成功指标

  • Insights that only emerged from combining multiple perspectives
  • Assumptions challenged and resolved into better solutions
  • Distinct voice and vocabulary for each adopted perspective
  • Productive tensions resolved into robust outcomes
  • Clear actionable recommendations with trade-off awareness
  • 仅通过多视角结合才产生的洞见
  • 假设被挑战并转化为更优解决方案
  • 每个采用的视角都有独特的表达和词汇
  • 建设性分歧转化为稳健的结果
  • 清晰的可落地建议，且能意识到权衡关系