related-work-writing

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English
🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

Related Work Writing

相关工作撰写

Generate publication-quality Related Work sections with proper citations and thematic organization.
生成符合出版标准的相关工作章节,具备规范的引用和主题化组织结构。

Input

输入

  • $0
    — Current paper draft or method description
  • $1
    — Collected literature (BibTeX entries, paper summaries, or literature review notes)
  • $0
    — 当前论文草稿或方法说明
  • $1
    — 收集的文献(BibTeX 条目、论文摘要或文献综述笔记)

References

参考资料

  • Related work writing prompts and strategies:
    ~/.claude/skills/related-work-writing/references/related-work-prompts.md
  • 相关工作写作提示与策略:
    ~/.claude/skills/related-work-writing/references/related-work-prompts.md

Workflow

工作流

Step 1: Analyze the Paper's Contributions

步骤1:分析论文的贡献

  • Read the current paper draft (especially Methods and Introduction)
  • Identify the key contributions and novelty claims
  • List the technical components that need literature context
  • 阅读当前论文草稿(尤其是方法和引言部分)
  • 确定核心贡献和创新性声明
  • 列出需要文献背景支撑的技术组件

Step 2: Organize Literature by Theme

步骤2:按主题整理文献

Group related papers into thematic clusters:
  • Each cluster should represent a research direction or technique
  • Common themes: problem formulation, methodology family, application domain, evaluation approach
  • Order themes from most to least relevant to your work
将相关论文归类到不同的主题集群中:
  • 每个集群代表一个研究方向或技术
  • 常见主题:问题表述、方法体系、应用领域、评估方案
  • 按与你的研究的相关性从高到低排序主题

Step 3: Write Each Theme Paragraph

步骤3:撰写每个主题段落

For each thematic group:
  1. Topic sentence — Introduce the research direction
  2. Describe key works — Summarize 2-5 representative papers
  3. Compare and contrast — How does each approach differ from yours?
  4. Transition — Connect to the next theme or to your contribution
针对每个主题组:
  1. 主题句 — 介绍该研究方向
  2. 描述关键研究 — 总结2-5篇代表性论文
  3. 对比分析 — 每种方法与你的研究有何不同?
  4. 过渡句 — 衔接下一个主题或你的研究贡献

Step 4: Refine

步骤4:优化润色

  • Ensure every cited paper has a clear reason for inclusion
  • Check that your work's novelty is clear from the comparisons
  • Verify all
    \cite{}
    keys exist in the
    .bib
    file
  • Aim for 1-2 pages (single column) or 0.5-1 page (double column)
  • 确保每篇被引用的论文都有明确的入选理由
  • 检查通过对比是否清晰体现了你的研究的创新性
  • 验证所有
    \cite{}
    键都存在于
    .bib
    文件中
  • 篇幅目标:1-2页(单栏)或0.5-1页(双栏)

Rules

规则

  • Compare and contrast, don't just describe — "Unlike [X] which assumes..., our method..."
  • Organize by theme, not chronologically — Group by research direction
  • Cite broadly — Not just the most popular papers; include recent and diverse work
  • Be fair — Acknowledge strengths of prior work before stating limitations
  • Explain inapplicability — If a method could apply to your setting, explain why you don't compare experimentally, or add it to experiments
  • Use present tense for established facts — "Smith et al. propose..." or "This approach uses..."
  • End with positioning — The final paragraph should clearly position your work relative to all discussed prior work
  • 对比分析,而非仅描述 — "不同于假设[X]的[某研究],我们的方法…"
  • 按主题组织,而非按时间顺序 — 按研究方向分组
  • 广泛引用 — 不仅引用最热门的论文,还要纳入近期的多元化研究
  • 客观公正 — 在说明先前研究的局限性之前,先承认其优势
  • 说明不适用性 — 如果某方法适用于你的研究场景,说明你为何不进行实验对比,或将其补充到实验中
  • 既定事实使用现在时 — "Smith等人提出…"或"该方法使用…"
  • 末尾明确研究定位 — 最后一段应清晰说明你的研究相对于所有讨论的先前研究的定位

Related Skills

相关技能

  • Upstream: literature-search, literature-review, citation-management
  • Downstream: paper-writing-section
  • See also: survey-generation
  • 上游:literature-searchliterature-reviewcitation-management
  • 下游:paper-writing-section
  • 另见:survey-generation