yt-audit

Compare original and translation side by side

🇺🇸

Original

English

🇨🇳

Translation

Chinese

yt-audit

An audit that lists twenty problems is a way of avoiding the one that matters. This ends in ONE fix.

列出二十个问题的审核，是回避唯一真正重要问题的方式。本次审核最终只给出一个修复项。

Before you write

开始撰写前

Read
```
~/.claude/youtube/voice.md
```
if it exists. That is the user's voice profile: how they talk on camera, the words they never use, who they are talking to, what they will not claim. If it does not exist, ask for three of their own videos, read or transcribe them, infer the voice, and write the file. A script in the wrong voice is worse than no script, because they have to read it out loud.
Never invent a number, a result or a source. If a figure would strengthen it and you do not have one, ask for it or write the line without it.

如果
```
~/.claude/youtube/voice.md
```
存在，请先阅读它。这是用户的语气档案：他在镜头前如何表达、从不使用哪些词、面向谁说话，以及不会做出哪些声明。如果该文件不存在，请让用户提供三个自己的视频，阅读或转录这些视频，推断其表达方式，然后写入该文件。语气错误的脚本比没有脚本更糟糕，因为用户还必须把它念出来。
绝不捏造数字、结果或来源。如果加入某个数据能增强内容，但你没有该数据，就向用户询问，或在不包含该数据的情况下完成这句话。

What to look at, in this order

按此顺序检查

The last ten titles, as a set. Read them as a list, the way the channel page shows them. Do they promise different things? Run them through
```
../yt-package/title.py
```
. A channel where every title is the same shape has a format problem, not a title problem.
The thumbnails, at feed size. Shrink them. What survives? If three of them are unreadable at that size, that is the fix and nothing else matters yet.
The first fifteen seconds of the three most recent. Transcribe them and score with
```
../yt-script/hookscore.py
```
. This is where most channels lose.
Upload rhythm. Not frequency - CONSISTENCY. Six videos in one week and then nothing for a month is worse than one a fortnight forever.
The retention shape, if they can export it.
```
/yt-retention
```
.

**将最近十个标题作为一个整体来看。**按照频道页面显示列表的方式阅读它们。这些标题是否承诺了不同的内容？将其传入
```
../yt-package/title.py
```
检查。如果每个标题都采用相同的结构，那么这是频道格式问题，而不是单个标题问题。
**以信息流尺寸查看缩略图。**将它们缩小。缩小后还能看清什么？如果其中三张在该尺寸下无法辨认，这就是当前要修复的问题，其他事项暂时都不重要。
**检查最近三个视频的前十五秒。**转录内容，并使用
```
../yt-script/hookscore.py
```
进行评分。大多数频道的用户都是在这里流失的。
发布节奏。重点不是频率，而是一致性。一周发布六个视频，然后停更一个月，不如每两周稳定发布一个视频，并长期保持。
留存曲线，如果用户可以导出相关数据。使用
```
/yt-retention
```
。

What to hand back

交付内容

The single biggest fix, named, with what to do this week.
Three things that are already working, so they do not break them. Be specific; "your energy is good" is not an observation.
What NOT to do yet, and why.

Never open an audit with praise you do not mean, and never end one with a list of twenty things.

明确指出最重要的一个修复项，并说明本周要采取什么行动。
指出三项已经做得很好的事情，避免用户破坏它们。具体说明；“你的精力很好”不算观察结论。
说明暂时不要做什么，以及原因。

绝不要用言不由衷的赞扬开始审核，也绝不要以二十项问题清单结束审核。

The gate

发布确认

Nothing here publishes. This skill writes and you publish. Every output ends in a block the user copies, and the last line of every run is the question: ship it, or change it?

本流程不会发布任何内容。这个 skill 负责撰写，由你负责发布。每份输出都以一个供用户复制的区块结束，并且每次运行的最后一行都是这个问题：直接发布，还是先修改？