ig-comment
Compare original and translation side by side
🇺🇸
Original
English🇨🇳
Translation
Chineseig-comment
ig-comment
Commenting is the highest-leverage twenty minutes on Instagram and the easiest
to do badly. A comment near the top of a reel with 40,000 views is seen by more
people than most accounts' own posts, and it is the one place where a stranger
can tap straight through to a profile.
A generic comment is worse than none. It costs a tap that goes nowhere and it
marks the account as an engagement-pod account to the one person whose opinion
mattered, which is the creator.
在 Instagram 上发表评论是投入产出比最高的二十分钟，也是最容易做砸的二十分钟。位于观看量达 40,000 的 Reel 顶部附近的一条评论，会被比大多数账号自己的帖子更多的人看到；这里也是唯一一个让陌生人可以直接点进个人主页的入口。
泛泛的评论还不如不发。它浪费一次毫无去向的点击，还会向那个最在意评价的人——也就是创作者——表明，这个账号就是个 engagement-pod 账号。
Input
输入
The user pastes the post or reel text, or a screenshot, with the account name.
If they give a URL you cannot open, ask them to paste it. Do not use a browser
tool to scrape the feed and do not post anything.
用户粘贴帖子或 Reel 的文字，或提供带账号名称的截图。
如果用户给出无法打开的 URL，请要求其粘贴内容。不要使用 browser tool 抓取 feed，也不要发布任何内容。
The nine comment types
九种评论类型
Pick by what the post actually is. Never default to type 1.
| # | type | when | shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Add a datum | the post makes a claim you can support with a number | "Same for us: 40% of..." |
| 2 | Add the missing case | the post is right but incomplete | "This holds until {condition}." |
| 3 | Respectful disagree | you genuinely think it is wrong | name the agreement first, then the fork |
| 4 | Extend one line | one line in it is the good one | quote it, build on it |
| 5 | Ask the real question | the post skipped the hard part | one question, specific |
| 6 | The receipt | you have done the thing they described | what happened, two sentences |
| 7 | The correction | there is a factual error | be right, be brief, be kind, be sure |
| 8 | The reframe | right facts, wrong frame | "Another way to read this:" |
| 9 | The one-liner | the post needs nothing, you want presence | under 10 words, must be funny or true |
根据帖子的实际内容选择类型。绝不默认使用类型 1。
| # | 类型 | 适用情形 | 结构 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 补充数据（Add a datum） | 帖子提出某个论点，而你可以用数字加以支持 | “我们也一样：40% 的……” |
| 2 | 补充缺失情形（Add the missing case） | 帖子说得对，但不完整 | “这个结论在{条件}出现前成立。” |
| 3 | 礼貌地表示异议（Respectful disagree） | 你真诚地认为它有误 | 先指出认同之处，再说明分歧所在 |
| 4 | 延展其中一句（Extend one line） | 其中有一句是精华 | 引用那句话并加以延展 |
| 5 | 提出真正的问题（Ask the real question） | 帖子跳过了最困难的部分 | 只问一个具体问题 |
| 6 | 实例佐证（The receipt） | 你做过帖子中描述的事 | 讲述实际经历，用两句话 |
| 7 | 纠正（The correction） | 存在事实错误 | 确保正确、简洁、友善且确有把握 |
| 8 | 重新解读（The reframe） | 事实无误，但切入角度不对 | “还可以这样理解：” |
| 9 | 一句话评论（The one-liner） | 帖子不需要补充，你只是想留下存在感 | 少于 10 个词，必须有趣或真实 |
Rules
规则
- One to three sentences. Instagram comments are read in a narrow column under a video. A paragraph gets collapsed behind "more" and nobody taps it.
- Never open with "Great post", "Love this", "So true", "This 👏", "Needed this today", or the creator's first name with an exclamation mark. All of them are invisible.
- No emoji-only comments and no emoji as the first character.
- Never restate the reel. Everybody watching just watched it.
- One idea. A comment with two points reads as a hijack.
- Say the specific thing. If the comment could sit under any post on the topic, it is not a comment, it is noise.
- No pitching, ever. Not the offer, not the link, not "check out my page". That is the fastest way to be blocked by exactly the person you were trying to reach.
- Early matters more here than anywhere. A comment in the first hour on a reel that then travels gets carried with it.
- 一至三句话。 Instagram 评论是在视频下方的狭窄栏位中阅读的。段落太长会被折叠在“更多”后面，没人愿意点开。
- 绝不能以“Great post”“Love this”“So true”“This 👏”“Needed this today”开头，也不要用带感叹号的创作者名字开头。这些开场白全都毫无存在感。
- 不要只发表情，也不要让 emoji 出现在首字符。
- 不要复述 Reel。 每个人都已经看过了。
- 只表达一个观点。 包含两个论点的评论会显得是在抢话。
- 说出具体内容。 如果一条评论可以原封不动地放在该主题下的任何帖子下面，那它就不是评论，只是噪声。
- 绝不推销。 不要提产品，不要发链接，也不要说“看看我的主页”。这是最快被你想触达的那个人拉黑的方式。
- 在这里，越早发布越重要。 如果 Reel 在首小时后继续传播，第一小时内的评论也会跟着被带上。
Output
输出
Give two options of different types, labelled, plus one line on which you
would post and why. Run both through first: comments are short, so
an em dash or a stock phrase is proportionally louder than it is in a caption.
/ig-humanCOMMENT OPTIONS (on @acct's reel about pricing)
[6 · Receipt]
We raised ours 40% last March and lost exactly one client, who was the one
taking up half the inbox. Took eight months to stop being scared of it.
[3 · Respectful disagree]
Agree on the anchoring. The part I would push back on is doing it mid-project.
We tried that and it cost us a renewal that was otherwise fine.
Post the first. It concedes something and it has a number in it.给出两种不同类型的评论选项并分别标注，再加一行说明你会发布哪一条以及原因。先将两者都通过 检查：评论很短，因此 em dash 或套话所占的比例会显得比在 caption 中更加刺耳。
/ig-humanCOMMENT OPTIONS (on @acct's reel about pricing)
[6 · Receipt]
We raised ours 40% last March and lost exactly one client, who was the one
taking up half the inbox. Took eight months to stop being scared of it.
[3 · Respectful disagree]
Agree on the anchoring. The part I would push back on is doing it mid-project.
We tried that and it cost us a renewal that was otherwise fine.
Post the first. It concedes something and it has a number in it.Batch mode
批量模式
For an engagement round, ask for the 5 to 10 posts as pasted text in one
message, return one comment each in a single block, and keep a running note in
of who has been commented on this week.
Commenting on the same three accounts every day is visible and it looks like
exactly what it is.
~/.claude/instagram/log.md对于一次互动轮次，请用户一次发送 5 到 10 条以文本形式粘贴的帖子，并集中为每条返回一条评论，同时在 中持续记录本周评论过哪些账号。
每天评论同样的三个账号非常显眼，而且会让人一眼看出你就是在刻意刷互动。
~/.claude/instagram/log.mdNever
绝不要
Do not auto-post, do not automate comments, and do not use a browser tool to
publish on the user's behalf. Automated engagement violates Instagram's Terms
of Use and gets accounts action-blocked. This skill writes the comment. The
user posts it.
不要自动发布，不要自动发表评论，也不要使用 browser tool 代表用户发布内容。自动化互动违反 Instagram's Terms of Use，并会导致账号遭到限制或封禁。这个 skill 只负责撰写评论，由用户自行发布。